Before he went silver for his role in the new X Men movies, Evan Peters already had quite the well-established career, as a star in the revolutionary American Horror Story. Despite my feelings toward the show and its decline over the seasons, AHS has given us the gift of Jessica Lange for those of us who were not alive in the 70s, appearances from the likes of Stevie Nicks, the soaring beauty of Liz Taylor as embodied by the welcome recurrence of Denis O’Hare – but most of all, Evan Peters.
Although in his other works Evan Peters has been shortchanged into the usual roles gifted (or cursed) to any of those with a youthful appearance at his not so tender age of 29, AHS has given us the gift of Peters’ versatility and growing talent. He is continuously challenged by AHS’ resident cast, with unique story lines that allow Peters to embrace his affinity with monsters.
His AHS career has been one of the most diverse the show has seen, playing roles from Frankenstein’s monster to mass murderer, and, as one of the longest running stars, the demands of the show and its ephemeral themes have never eluded him. Breadth of age and character has revealed his flexibility whilst showcasing his attention to detail for each of the complex creations: the physicality of Kyle and James March; the passion of Kit Walker and circus freak Jimmy; the humanity and weakness behind Tate Langdon, his first and most controversial role. He lives and breathes each time and space, fitting comfortably within the modern seasons as well as those filmed in a different period; an immersive experience for both actor and spectator.
His voice work is equally paramount to his success. The cadenced culture of the 20s and 30s heard in the voice of James March, created by Peters himself, was truly an echo of a former time, if only idealised and mimicked by the character. It acted as March’s mask of similitude to a world he was never a part of, apart from when let down by the very human feeling of anger. March was a game changer for Peters; a mockery and parasite of the society he lived in and a character completely unlike anything he had done before. He had had encounters with monsters before, and found the human within the inhuman, but the morbid fascination he needed to inspire from such an infamous figure in history was no easy task. While the rest of the cast still felt familiar, which is one of the reasons it is well on its way to curing me of my fear of horror – probably not what the creators had in mind – Peters felt completely new, spontaneous, and terrifying.
Although I praise Peters, many of his characters have been similar in one respect. They were not men, but boys, a twisted bildungsroman in each series just waiting to happen. James Patrick March changed all this. It gave testament to Peters’ ability as an actor, and his ability to completely transform and inhabit an atypical character. The teenage boy replaced by the enigmatic man.
Did you know?
- He and fellow co-star Aaron Taylor Johnson from Kick-Ass have both played Quicksilver recently on the big screen.
- His favourite character (and mine) to play in AHS was Tate Langdon (Series 1, Murder House).
- He will be in the new series of American Horror Story – the theme of which is yet to be revealed.
The series that you need to watch:
Disclaimer – This is ranked in terms of Evan Peters’ characters, and not in terms of series supremacy.
- Murder House – Definitive in every sense, the first season of AHS was genuinely frightening and, in my humble opinion, the best of the bunch. Tate Langdon is a masterpiece of teenage angst and terrible secrets, splattered with Peters’ most recognisable style of fast paced dialogue and messy flop of hair.
- Hotel – James Patrick March, a parody of 1920s/30s society, is a new side to Peters’ we have never seen, and I’m not complaining.
- Asylum/Coven – Asylum and Coven are quite equally matched. Both interesting characters for Peters to play around with; Coven sees a wonderful physical performance by Peters of a monster who feels emotions but cannot express them, and in Asylum a good man accused of murder and his search for truth and sanity.
- Freak Show – Although Jimmy Darling is one of my favourites, it felt like the least demanding performance by Peters. To be honest, when it comes to Evan Peters, the creepier the better, while the sentiment behind Freak Show was to reveal the barbarity of humanity and the humanity of the freaks.
See the trailer for the latest season of American Horror Story, Hotel, which stars Evan Peters as James Patrick Marsh, below.